Enlivening the curriculum of health-related fitness

Tags: Rebecca J. Lloyd, Stephen J. Smith, Educational Insights, Health-Related Fitness, Curriculum, movement, Rebecca Lloyd, optimal health, HRF, Journal of Aesthetic Education, body composition, mindfulness, physical education, posture, assessment, cosmic breath, Rudolf Laban, Garcia Bengoechea, London, Journal of Physical Activity & Health, Cambridge University Press, References Alberta Learning, space awareness, Alberta, Canada, Health-Related Fitness Lloyd, Health-Related Fitness Rebecca J. Lloyd, Stephen Moore, Simon Fraser University, Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, Women's Fitness, ebbs and flows, Authors Rebecca J. Lloyd, Health-Related Fitness Aronld, Journal of Physical Education Recreation and Dance, Ontario Ministry of Education, muscular strength, cardiovascular capacity, assessment purposes, optimal alignment, Health Education Journal, Ontario Ministry of Education Curriculum, Qualitative Health Research, Inner Traditions International, New York, Northwestern University Press, Rebecca, Stephen Smith, John Benjamins, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company Inc.
Content: Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness Lloyd, R.J. and Smith, S.J. (2009). Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness Educational Insights, 13(4). [Available: http://www.ccfi.educ.ubc.ca/publication/insights/v13n04/articles/lloyd_smith/index.html] Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness Rebecca J. Lloyd University of Ottawa Stephen J. Smith Simon Fraser University
©Rebecca Lloyd- Balancing on a rock
Page 1 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness
Is More Better? Counting Repetitions VS Considerations of What Really Counts
There is a sadomasochistic tone to the commercialized industry of health and fitness." Get
moving and stop being a couch potato!" Such admonishments from taut trainers with "abs
of steel" require clients to become "the Biggest Losers." Instructors are paid to scream and
whip bodies into shape. Bodies are hardened to the fashionable contours of workout apparel
by being dragged through the trenches, through "boot camps," and "body attacks." Against
such a context, as educators inspired by the joys of movement, we ask about a different
approach to health and fitness.
Instead of punishing the body, I know what Robinson (2002) means when she describes the fit what if a gentle, sympathetic body as being "strong, [...] primarily male" and "significantly
unleashing of bodily vigor rooted in war" to the extent where "the female body's softness is
and vitality were promoted? What if becoming fit and healthy became the consequence of feeling the
banished" (14-17). As I experienced a scaled down version of bodybuilding as a fitness educator and emerging competitor who secured the title of Women's Fitness Champion in 1999, I was drawn into the implicit competition within the socially constructed walls of the gym environment of who can be the biggest or the
movements that are bodily satisfying, forming motions that are vitally engaging, and experiencing a flow of connection with others?
hardest. I loved being around other strong lifters and preferred it if they were male. I thrived on their energy and feeling just as strong as they were. The more I lifted weights, the stronger I felt. It didn't matter that I was going to sleep at night in agony. What mattered most was that I stuck to my regime. I loved the feeling of the all consuming push, press, or pull. I just treated my body
as something that could be fixed by physiotherapy or chiropractic
The present curricula of
treatments. I was not willing to change my approach and draw
health-related fitness (HRF) in Education tend to reinforce
upon the kinaesthetic sensitivities I developed as a former professionally trained ballet dancer, the sixth sense otherwise known as "proprioception" (Sheets-Johnstone, 1998, 154). I
the wider, societal view by exuded the "no pain no gain" approach to becoming fit that
separating physiological
Stephen Moore (1996) describes in his exploration of the Go[l]d's
functioning from what we
Gym body. Although my pain wasn't comparable to what Mr.
would like to identify as the kinaesthetic and somaesthetic
Olympia felt as he ripped his biceps in his bent over row of 405 pounds, I can appreciate the feeling he had the "morning of the contest, a 260 pound Dorian `as hard as ever' as he "emerged
registers of consciousness. As from the tomb, or at least the dressing room, with his eyes set
we draw attention to the "self- on the prize" (Moore, 1996, 105). I, too, was caught up in the
sensing, internalized perception of oneself" associated with the Greek term "soma" (Hanna, 1988,
process of what I thought was physically perfecting myself. I was making changes to shake off my graceful exterior so that I could walk onto a fitness competition stage and flex my way into winning my women's fitness trophy and my sought-after place among other hard-bodied leaders of fitness leaders.
20) and the aesthetic "here
Page 2 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness
20) and the aesthetic "here
and now" (Arnold, 2005, 50)
attitude that permits a present
moment consciousness, we
invite you to consider how the
curricula of HRF may be
permeated by a feeling,
forming, flowing approach
that puts us in touch with the
"beautiful form in all human
activity" (Alter, 2004, 27) At
present, quantitative
parameters, such as minutes
of activity, repetitions of a
muscular conditioning
exercise, or the relative girth
measures between waist and
hip (cf. Smith & Lloyd,
2007), indicate the degree to
which one is becoming
healthy. There is little room
©Rebecca Lloyd - Women's Fitness Champion
for what Shusterman (2008)
describes as a "somaesthetic"
quality of movement and
what Csikszentmihalyi (2000)
profiles as the optimal,
psychological state of flow.
In fact, present revisions to secondary health and physical education curricula, which aim to
increase levels of physical activity and lifelong wellness are now, more than ever,
influenced by the scientization of movement (see for example Education Alberta, 2008; and
the proposed revisions to the Ontario Health & Physical Education Curriculum, 2009).
Youth inactivity and
Otis catches the tail end of his grade eleven physical and health
Childhood Obesity, framed by education teacher's announcement, "We are going to test your
the problem of "globesity" Health-Related Fitness today" as he saunters into the gym.
(Gibbons & Naylor, 2007), fuel the HRF push in schools with its emphasis on indices of body composition, aerobic
"Gulp." Otis thinks back to the last two weeks he just spent on winter vacation, begins to mentally log moments that might affect his current state of fitness. "Perfecting his 360's on his snowboard in the terrain park must count. Right?" For an instant he is transported back in time where he hits a jump with
capacity, muscular strength, excessive speed and propels himself to a dangerously new
endurance, and flexibility (Plowman et al., 2006). The almost exclusive emphasis on such quantitative,
height... "Otis!" Mr. Munroe snaps as he invites him to hold the callipers, the metal tweezer-like pinchers that clasp the palpable squishy layer of what the teacher described as `adipose tissue' held fast to Danny's 90 degree-angled arm. "Danny's an avid weight lifter and look what I can pinch," thought Otis, wondering
physiological indices leaves about his own layers of fat as he continued to pinch his calf and
little room for understanding how one may be "physically educated through and by means of fitness-based
trunk skin folds... Fading feelings of embarrassment only resurface as he begins the beep test where he must run back and forth between lines set at a distance of 20 meters apart. "At what point do I stop trying to hang on?" thought Otis as he tried to keep pace with the set cadence. With exasperation he knew it
activities" (Lloyd & Smith, in was no longer a decision he could make. The rhythm caught
press) that focus on a qualitative, enlivening engagement of being present with one's body and breath.
him, outsmarted him and orchestrated a different pace reserved for the elite athletes in the class. Next came the "curl-up" station which was very fitting as all Otis wanted to do was curl over, catch his breath for awhile and chill out. His best buddy Robbie
Page 3 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness
with one's body and breath. coaxed, "Come on Otis, just get this over with" as he helped him
keep track of how maNY Times he could curl up within a minute.
If HRF assessment is to inform the learning process, we may consider alternatives to anatomical and
The prone trunk lift station was a nice change of pace as the boys just had to lift up once and measure the distance between the torso and the floor. "Almost finished," thought Otis as he saw the remaining "Push-up" and "Back-saver Sit and Reach" stations ahead. "But maybe I'll just rest here for a minute," Otis thought
physiological quantifications as he rolled over on the mat and drifted to feeling of big air.
of body composition, cardiovascular capacity, muscular strength, and
"Next time, 720" he thought as he visualised the speed he would need to enter the ramp, "Tooooooot." Mr. Munroe's hardened gaze signified the assessment wasn't over yet...
endurance and flexibility, that
date back to the 1950s
(Keating, Silverman &
Kulinna, 2002, 194).
We suggest that conceptions of body composition may extend beyond measured muscle to
fat ratios, and that assessments may include somatic sensations of tightness and ease that
relate to the way we posture ourselves in the world. And from this enhanced awareness, we
may form strengthening, stretching and cardiovascular enhancing movement experiences
that pulsate with corporeal vitality.
At present, the dominant forward flexing movements assessed within the curriculum of HRF such as the repetitive push-up (which shortens and tightens the chest), sit-up (which promotes a forward flexion of the spine), and sustained sit-and-reach test, may act as bodily blocks to the development of optimal health. According to Keating (2003), the design of a personalized workout will most likely consist of exercises experienced in a HRF assessment. Unfortunately, if this is the case, students will become progressively tighter in their chests and rounded in their upper backs. And given the behaviorist, instructional model associated with HRF (Metlzer, 2005), it is unlikely that a student encounters a teacher who will respond to the design of a healthy living plan with respect to the postural implications of the selected exercises and stretches and with the intent of having the student feel his or her way into optimal alignment.
Current exemplars provided for physical education teachers to assist them with the assessment of a student's personalized active and healthy living plan do not take into account features of functional and experiential anatomy where the synergistic movements add up to a greater projection and sensation of energy in optimal alignment and function. What becomes evident in these examples provided for assessment purposes is a disconnected, mechanistic understanding of the body, for which it doesn't matter what one does as long as there is progressive overload over time. For example, the highest scoring exemplar features a grade eleven student who writes, "I will stretch before each workout for 5 minutes, do 15 push-ups to start, and gradually increase the number of reps" (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2008, 2). What is missing from this and other exemplars is an enlivened understanding of HRF that is rooted in the process of feeling, forming and flowing one's way towards optimal health.
Feeling: Enlivening the Flesh through Breath
Sensation is not just the messenger of pain, discomfort, and other emotions, but is the link to an extraordinary aesthetic landscape that is our birthright. --Conrad, 2007, xxiii-xxiv
Page 4 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness If we continue to promote the `more is better' approach to becoming fit and the physical hardening that accompanies the counting of disconnected repetitions that form the curriculum of HRF and popular boot camp regimes, we dampen the possibility of sensing and feeling all there is to experience within movement. Dancers, who may be considered experts of sensing "the aesthetics of stance and motion," develop enhanced sensitivities to "the poetry of movement in everything around them--a newspaper blowing down the sidewalk, a bird landing on the telephone wire--and in everything they do, like setting the table and sipping coffee" (Tuan, 1993, 38-39). Such sensitivities change the way one experiences life as they open up the possibilities of feeling the gentle warmth, waves and gradual surges of pleasure. They also inform us of how certain bodily postures and motions may create feelings of discomfort and dis-ease long before the threshold of pain takes hold. While a disconnected consciousness surrounds most of our physical education (Myers, 1998) and health promoting practices, such as running on a treadmill while watching television or lifting weights while chatting to a friend, and while such practices lend support to Foucault's assertion, that "vivid somatic consciousness does not arise unless the body is somehow engaged in violent sensations" (Shusterman, 2008, 38), we assert that the key to experiencing optimal health rests on sensing such simple pleasures as the breathing that expands and inspires a connection to others and to the natural world. ©Rebecca Lloyd- Breathing in a Moment Experiencing the curriculum of HRF from an internal, kinaesthetic register requires awareness of the fluid motions of the vital breath that shape the pathways of expansion and contraction from the musculoskeletal right down to the cellular level. How we breathe influences our posture, how we move, and how we position ourselves in the world. Every inhalation creates form while every exhalation dissolves form. For some, attending to the coalescing and dissolving qualities of respiration shapes the pathway, cadence and intertwining of extension and contraction in mind-body disciplines such as Yoga or Pilates. For others who are open to the insights of quantum science, the "very act of breathing becomes a universal respiration reflecting the basic motif of organismic life" (Conrad, Page 5 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness
xxiii). More than the passage of air, breathing suggests that forming and dispersing actions are what keep us in "fluid resonance," not only with each other, but inspired by the pulsating stars over our heads (xxii).
One may begin to experience breath by locating the depth of its travel. Is it resting in the upper quadrant of the lungs or moving downward in the direction of the underbelly? Using the hand as a guide, consider tracing the pathway of the respiration cycle and the gestural shape it makes: Is it a linear journey from the downward phase of intake to the expelling upward release, or does it take on the helix-like crisscrossing of ocean currents of energy which resemble the shape of "the winged Hermes staff with the twined serpents" (33); the symbol of western medicine? The philosophy of Hatha-Yoga suggests the latter, as the points of intersection become energy centers otherwise known as "chakras" (Rosen, 2002). While much can be said for understanding and tuning into the various properties of each energy centre, knowledge of the specific function of each chakra is not essential for the beginning breather. Simply imagining the flow of the water-like current of the breath coiling up and down the spine is enough to add a vitality sustaining and provoking dimension to what could initially be conceived as a linear, dead-end pathway.
Feeling the pathway, amplitude, and steady cadence of the breath in sedentary positions may serve to deepen respiration, but ultimately, if the curriculum of HRF is to be enlivened, this growing somatic awareness needs to be contrasted with our assessments of body composition as a function of muscle to fat ratios. Sensing one's body composition beyond this HRF reductionism, students may learn, for example, to connect to a kinaesthetic sense of posture. Hodgson (2001) suggests that
Fitness begins with posture. The human body stands upright, against gravitational pull, and needs to learn how to control and harness the tensions that result from this conflict. Balance and harmony should be the keynote to good stance, as elsewhere. Recognizing the structure of the body and working always with a regard for its symmetry, individual posture is a prime consideration and the basis for all activity. --Hodgson, 205, 206
If the curriculum of HRF were to include postural analysis, conceptual connections may be
made between the way we stand in everyday life and the meaning behind and within the
multiplicity of our extending and contractile capabilities. Breathing into various body parts
invites us to soften tensions that have an unconscious hold (Hanna, 1998) on how we
comport ourselves in everyday life. In anatomical terms, we are likely to experience either
the "shoulder (proximal) crossed syndrome [1] " or the "pelvic crossed syndrome [2] "
(Hammer, 1999, 417-418). But for those who better understand postures in somatic terms,
these same imbalances can be thought of as (a) the "red light" or "startle reflex, a fear, or
withdrawal response in which we instinctively hunch forward to try to protect ourselves"
and (b) the
"green light reflex" which is
"caused by the tightening of the
muscles in the back of the body" as we "arch up and back slightly as
As you breathe in, you may feel a natural elongation and stretch of your spine. When you exhale, do you feel a
we prepare to move into action" grounding sense of release? Simply tuning into these
(Dreaver & Provasoli, 1999, 396). sensations in anything you do from sitting and writing to
walking and cycling has the capacity to transform a
To alleviate tensions associated
potential depleting and exhausting experience into one that
Page 6 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness
To alleviate tensions associated with such imbalances, we may invite students to breathe into and mobilize their various joints.
is radiating with rejuvenating vitality. Writing or excessive reading in front of a computer, for example, has a tendency to draw one into a kyphotic slump, particularly if the text is interesting and a forward lean towards the
Coupling the breath to motions of screen takes hold. Without somatic intervention, the
elevation and depression, protraction and retraction and well as circular wave-like motions of circumduction thus provides
sustained forward crouch may lend itself to the onset of fatigue, discomfort, or even musculoskeletal pain. Simply pausing for a moment, rolling your shoulders forward and upward during an inhalation and backward and downward during an exhalation has the potential to enliven any
students with sensory information seated position. As the circular motion becomes
about the multiple ways they can expand or shorten musculature connected to their various bony protuberances. Rather than
seamlessly connected to the phases of respiration, you may gradually reduce the size of the shoulder circles and find a place of symmetrical and sustainable rest. Similarly, as you tune into your lower torso, you may begin to couple an inhalation with a gentle arch of your lower back and an
perpetuating the learning of
exhalation with a rounded release. Over the span of a
anatomy from an objective distance minute or two, the rocking, breath-led motion of spinal
(see for example the newly proposed Ontario Exercise Science
extension and contraction may gradually dissipate so that you are able to feel a slight difference between the two-- just enough of an arch to feel extension and just enough of
Grade 12 health and physical
a bend to feel a shortening of the spine--and thus feel
education course available through yourself into an ideal posture. Consider the difference
the Ontario Ministry of Education, between responding to a "sit up straight" cue versus
2009) students may begin to appreciate that "[a]lignment is a
experiencing this approach of feeling and forming your way into optimal alignment.
condition that you want to feel
into" (Johnson, 2000, 38).
Consider the difference, not only with respect to confidence building but also in relation to the ability to somatically process cues for alignment, if sensation were to take precedence over, say, external cues barked by a boot camp instructor or physical education teacher insisting "shoulders back" or "abs in." By subtly experimenting with wave-like elevations, depressions, protractions, retractions and circumductions of the shoulder blades for example, students may move away from the harshness and excessive end-range tensions associated with military postures, such as jamming the shoulder blades down and together, and feel the mobile freedom created by widening and floating them into a stress-free position. When neutral alignment is attained through such proprioceptive means, we open ourselves up to experiencing postures and positions that carry optimal radiations of vitality and functional energy (Johnson, 1996). And the more that we are able to relieve extraneous tensions and refine our postures for breathing, the more likely it is that we will sense the inherent joy and vitality within movement itself (Sheets-Johnstone, 1999; Stern, 2004).
Linking inspiration to the coalescence of form and expiration to the dissolution of form, as Conrad (2007) has done, helps us understand more fully the development of cardiovascular, strength, and flexibility promoting movements. Rather than conceptualizing HRF as a set of planned exercises that focus on strengthening individual areas of the body with the longterm risk of creating homeostatic misalignment, as in counting the number of push-ups one can complete without considering the overall balance between pushing and pulling motions, the interplay of breath and form helps us approach the curriculum of HRF with an inspirational, organic feel (Lloyd, Garcia Bengoechea & Smith, in press). To breathe in is to experience expansion and extension. To exhale is to experience contraction. While some mind-body practices accentuate certain phases of respiration such as "lengthening the
Page 7 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness inhalation or holding the breath after inhalation [...which has an] effect of energizing [... and] heating the body" (Desikachar, 1995, 39), it is also advised that a balance be always present between the phases of the breath since "too much fire without elimination can create disturbing patterns of energy. To receive that which is new energy, we must first release that which is old and no longer benefits us" (Desikachar, 39). If we reconsider how the breath may create a pathway to forming our various expansions and contractions within the motions that form the HRF curriculum, we may understand viscerally how a push-up motion, an exercise that shortens and tightens the chest, should be coupled with an exercise that promotes a retractive rowing of the shoulder blades to create a dynamic sense of bodily balance. Beyond the aesthetic creation of sculpting the outer layers of form, moving with a balance created by breath-centered awareness also provides a sense of connectivity and meaning in the gestures and motions that form the curriculum of physical education as well as those of everyday life. For example, while push-ups and rowing motions naturally translate into the strengthening of sending and receiving actions contextualized within games, they may also connect, motionally, and emotionally, to the actions of pushing a friend or a loved one away or, alternatively, drawing them close. Continuing this path of contemplation, we may also make a parallel connection between a game that loses the sense of rejuvenating vitality if one player continually dominates possession of a ball and an embrace that squeezes out the possibility of taking another breath. Conceptualizing all movement in relation to the balance and motile qualities of respiration has the potential to enliven more than the curriculum of HRF but the elementary and secondary curricula as well. Elsewhere we have critiqued not only the disconnected movements that form the design of HRF assessment, but also the mechanistic, disembodied way in which the elementary physical and Health Education curricula and resource guides present fundamental movements of the body (Lloyd & Smith, 2005). To breathe in is to expand and to exhale is to contract, an "original kinetic bodily pairings" which SheetsJohnstone (1999, 157) also relates to the opening and closing of one's mouth or the simple bipedal action of placing one foot after another. If we are able to conceptually frame all movement forms around such conceptions of the breath, we may revise lists of fundamental movements that objective bodies can do such as "receiving: e.g. catching, collecting; retaining: e.g. dribbling, carrying, bouncing, trapping; sending: e.g. throwing, kicking, striking" (Alberta Learning, 2000, our italics), and view them in relation to breath-inspired pairings. At present, support documents are provided to teachers that encourage the planning of a lesson around one fundamental movement skill at a time such as `throwing' (see for example www.phecanada.ca). By encouraging teachers to conceptualize movement in relation to `original kinetic bodily pairings' that trace us back to the phases of flowing respiration, lessons on `throwing' would naturally include receptive actions of `catching' and the natural flow that emerges. As variations in tempo, force, grace, flexibility and intertwining of relationality inform the maturing process, visceral, fluid and flowing connections can be made within and across various curricula. Actions related to sending and receiving can thus be connected to the pushing and pulling motions emphasized within the HRF curriculum at the secondary level. Flowing A student who is able to maintain a connection to breath-led movement, whether balancing synergistically her muscular expansions and contractions or becoming attuned to ebbs and flows on a cellular level, comes to understand the rhythmical qualities of movement. The motions of such a student become seemingly effortless, extending from one position to the Page 8 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness next in bursts, rushes, ebbs and flows that energize, synergize and resonate with the demands of the milieux of action. Rudolf Laban, a former dancer, choreographer and movement practitioner from earlier part of the last century was the first to incorporate concepts of effort (i.e. force, timing and flow) as well as principles of bodily awareness, space awareness, and relationality within the process of becoming physically educated (Laban & Lawrence, 1974; Laban, 1948). Within the framework of a mechanistic curriculum, however, the intentions behind Laban's concepts have never been truly realized. But now, as our interest revolves around enlivening the HRF curriculum, we return to Laban's interest in vitality and degrees of liveliness as correlations of the emotions and the intellect (Hodgson, 2001, 66). Influenced by Delcroze, and Delsarte, Laban's work reveals the harmonies of body and soul, particularly as that harmony is expressed in the release of natural and vital rhythms within the body (Hodgson, 2001, 68). Laban's description of a dancer's movement approaches what Conrad includes in her cosmic breath and what Merleau-Ponty (1968) describes as an elemental intertwining of the flesh of the body and the flesh of the world. Behind external events the dancer perceives another, entirely different, world. There is an energy behind all occurrences and material things for which it is almost impossible to find a name. A hidden, forgotten landscape lies there, the land of silence; the realm of the soul, and in the centre of this soul stands the swinging temple. Yet, the messages from this land of silence are tremendously eloquent and tell us of everchanging forms and shapes about things and realities important to us all. What we generally call dance also comes from these regions, and the dance-conscious person is truly an inhabitant of this land, consciously and directly drawing strength for living from its inexhaustible treasures. The remaining people can but get a taste of this vital nourishment through the enjoyment they derive from artistic works of dance. --Laban, 1975, 89, 90 One does not require a dance teacher to experience that "movement is the essence of life... [...and an] outward expression of the living energy within" (Laban, 1948, 101). Under the care of an educator who draws attention to the vitalizing qualities of the breath, students may learn to dance their way through any movement such as a push-up where undulations of the landscape may be sensed through waves of pressure oscillating between one's fingertips and the far reaches of the palms. Sensations that may be intensified through what Mullis' (2006) describes as the "principle of opposition" alive within aesthetic moments that afford the sustainability of "precarious balance" in variations of challenge (e.g. feeling the intensified affects of weight transfer in one's palms if the push-up hinges to that of Yoga's `downward facing dog' or inverts in the direction of a balanced handstand). With enough encouragement and attention to the breath-invoked sensation of movement, further refinement is possible, especially if conceptions of Conrad's cosmic breath are fully embraced. And so, as students depart from accustomed practices of counting one hardening repetition after another, they may instead attune themselves to the quality of their breath in the rhythmical motions of horizontal risings and fallings. Within such motions, "the quality of the breath is extremely important because it expresses our inner feelings. If we are in pain it shows in our breathing" (Desikachar, 1995, 13) and if we are to move toward the experience of pleasure we may sense whether our breath becomes shallow, deep, elevated Page 9 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness or slowed. The holding of one's breath, a common practice in stressful situations, is a central indication that one is not connecting to the visceral flow of movement.
©Rebecca Lloyd - Pregnant Woman
To experience the fluidities of movement, not only in the progressive skillbuilding way that Csikszentmihalyi (2000) profiles, but also in relation to what Leder (1996) describes as our "deeper visceral foundation" (203), we might connect consciously to the fluid passing of breath in various moments of our day. If the
Welcome rays of morning sun as you disrupt my cocoon of numbness and smile at me through heavy hanging slits of forest green. Let me be energetically lifted by your rays of sparkling warmth that penetrate the folds of my flesh, folds that have survived tremendous stretching and shrinking since the pregnancy and birth of my second son. I am moved by the magical sound of silence that enables me to suspend my mothering responsibilities to soak in a sun-drenched moment and somatically connect to my own physicality. I tiptoe toward my sliding patio bedroom door and gently sweep a panel of fabric aside to provide my freshly uncoiled yoga mat with a view of the rising sun. Bodily memories of my former life as a professional ballet dancer and women's fitness champion, two opposing endpoints of supple sensitivity and hardened exteriority, fuse together as I actively experience an
Page 10 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness
moments of our day. If the aesthetic curriculum of health and fitness. I begin a spontaneous
breath is flowing, we
series of flowing yoga and Pilates-inspired exercises designed to
experience the ebbs and
squeeze out the vacuous space beneath my retreating navel, still recovering from the inversion-producing stretch, as my folds of
flows of vitality entering our flesh are drawn together both inwards and upwards providing
bodies as we engage in the postural support for the gentle wavelike sway of spinal flexion,
cosmic dance of respiration. extension and rotation. My concern is not for my outer physique as
From combative sports to I secretly enjoy this time where my typically boyish frame softens in
juggling and, yes, even lovemaking, sensing the
milk-producing voluptuous fertility. My attention is not directed externally toward my outer `form' but internally with the intention of creating sensory or `feeling' pathways of re-acquaintance, pathways
fluid flow of energy of the that will eventually support complicated variations of strength,
breath in everything we do flexibility and cardiovascular grace.
may reverse apprehensions
and "the anguish of having
a body on this earthly
mission" (Conrad, 2007,
27). Simply remembering to
breathe steps
us away from the fallacious "more is better" ride to ecstasy or the addictive sensation of the
weight-room "pump."
If the breath is flowing
Optimal health is about much more than the attainment of a physiological capacity for strenuous movement. The kind of physical functioning accentuated in present HRF curricula needs to be complimented with an inspired capacity for movement that connects such functioning to movement feeling, which is to say, to kinaesthetic and proprioceptive senses of form. Breath, that most essential function of living forms, provides direct, visceral inspiration. Breathing life into functional movement, it becomes possible to appreciate the vast range of postural, gestural and expressive forms that extend well beyond the confines of games, sports, and even dance. Breath is more than the exchange of gases. It is the flow of energy and vitality that rightly distinguishes health and wellness. Feeling, forming, and flowing our way into an enlivened curriculum, we assert that the key to experiencing optimal health rests in the simple pleasures of sensing the delicate perturbations within our breath, and the postural, gestural, and expressive elaborations of breathing, that connect us to this human and more than human world.
[1] The "shoulder (proximal) crossed syndrome" exhibits an "elevation and protraction of the shoulders and a forward head posture" (Hammer, 1999, 417-418). [2] The "pelvic crossed syndrome" consists of weak abdominals and gluteus maximus muscles in conjunction with tight iliopsoas (hip flexor) and erector spinae muscles that cause a forward or anterior tipping of the pelvis (Hammer, 1999 417-418).
References Alberta Learning (2000). Physical education guide to implementation, Alberta, Canada accessed June 2006 from http://education.alberta.ca. Alter, J. B. (2004). Aesthetics in action. Journal of Physical Education Recreation and Dance JOPERD, 75(7), 27.
Page 11 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness Aronld, P. J. (2005). Somaesthetics, education and the art of dance. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 39(1), 48-64. Conrad, E, (2007). Life on land: The story of continuum. Berkeley: North Atlantic. Desikachar, TKV (1995). The Heart of Yoga: Developing a Personal Practice. Rochester, Vermont: Inner Traditions International. Dreaver, J. & Provasoli, R. (1999). Somatic technique. In Hammer (Ed.) Functional Soft Tissue Examination and Treatment by Manual Methods: New Perspectives, Second Edition. Norwalk, Connecticut: Aspen. 395-413. Gibbons, S. L., & Naylor, P. J. (2007). Whole school obesity prevention models: Considerations for secondary schools. Physical and Health Education Journal, 72(4), 8-13. Hanna, T. (1988). Somatics: Reawakening the Mind's Control of Movement, Flexibility, and Health. New York: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company Inc. Hammer, W. I. (1999) Muscle imbalance and postfacilitation stretch. In Hammer (Ed.) Functional Soft Tissue Examination and Treatment by Manual Methods: New Perspectives, Second Edition. Norwalk, Connecticut: Aspen. 415-445. Hodgson, John. (2001). Mastering movement: The life and work of Rudolf Laban. London: Methuen. Johnson, W. (2000). Aligned, relaxed, resilient: The physical foundations of mindfulness. Boston: Shambhala. Keating, X. D. (2003). The current often implemented fitness tests in physical Education Programs: Problems and future directions. Quest, 55, 141-160. Laban, Rudolf. (1948). Modern educational dance. London: Macdonald and Evans. Laban, Rudolf & Lawrence, F. C. (1974). Effort. Estover, Plymouth, UK: Macdonald and Evans. Laban, Rudolf (1975). A life for dance. New York: Theatre Arts. Translated by Lisa Ullmann. Leder, D. Flesh and Blood. In Welton, D. (Ed.), The Body (200 ­ 210). Massachusetts, USA.: Blackwell. Lloyd, R. J., Garcia Bengoechea, E., & Smith, S. J. (in press). Theories of learning. In R. Bailey (Ed.), Physical education for learning: A guide for secondary schools (1-20). London, England: Continuum. Lloyd, R. J., & Smith, S. J. (in press). Health-related fitness: Enlivening the physical education experience. In E. Singleton & A.Varpalotai (Eds.), Pedagogy for the moving body: Establishing a community of inquiry for studies in human movement (1-33). London, ON: Althouse. Page 12 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness Merleau-Ponty, M. (1968) translated by Alphonso Lingis, The Visible and the Invisible. Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press. Metzler, M. (2005). Instructional models for physical education (2nd ed.). AZ: Holcomb Hathaway. Mullis, E. C. (2006). Performative somaesthetics: Principles and scope. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 40(4), 104-117. Myers, T. (1998) Kinesthetic dystonia: what bodywork can offer a new physical education. Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, Vol. 2, No. 2, 101-114. Ontario Ministry of Education Curriculum Review Website for Health and Physical Education, Grades 1-12, accessed May 12, 2009, from http://www.curriculumreview.ca. Plowman, S. A., Sterling, C. L., Corbin, C. B., Meredith, M. D., Welk, G. J., & and Morrow, J. R. (2006). The history of FITNESSGRAM®. Journal of Physical Activity & Health, 3(Suppl. 2), S5­S20. Pronger, B. (1995) Rendering the Body: The Implicit Lessons of Gross Anatomy. Quest. 47, 427-446. Robinson, L. (2002) Black Tights: Women, Sport, and Sexuality. Toronto, Canada: Harper Collins. Rosen, R. (2002). The Yoga of Breath: A Step-by-Step Guide to Pranayama. Boston: Shambhala. Sheets-Johnstone, M. (1999) The Primacy of Movement. Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Shustermn, R. (2008). Body consciousness: A philosophy of mindfulness and somaesthetics. New York: Cambridge University Press. Smith, S. J., & Lloyd, R. J. (2006). Promoting vitality in health and physical education. Qualitative Health Research, 16(2), 245-267. Smith, S. J., & Lloyd, R. J. (2007). The assessment of vitality: An alternative to quantifying the health-related fitness experience. AVANTE, 11(3), 66-76. Stern, D.N. (2004). The Present Moment in Psychotherapy and Everyday Life. New York: W.W. Norton & Company. 23-54. Tuan, Y. (1993). Passing strange and wonderful: aesthetics, nature, and culture. Washington, D.C.: Island Press/Shearwater Books. About the Authors Rebecca J. Lloyd, is an Assistant Professor in Faculty of Education at the University of Ottawa in Canada who promotes interdisciplinarity in health and Page 13 of 14
Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness physical education through combining principles of pedagogy, sport psychology and curriculum understanding. In collaboration with Stephen Smith, she has developed a motion-sensitive phenomenological approach to research and has explored the experience of flow in exercise pedagogy and the presence of vitality in physical education. Currently, Stephen and Rebecca are developing a `Physical Mindfulness Model' that fleshes out kinaesthetic pathways towards experiencing enhanced flow and vitality in physical education, physical activity and sport performance contexts. Email: [email protected] Stephen Smith is Associate Professor and Director of Professional Programs at Simon Fraser University. His scholarly work pertains to curricular and instructional practices in physical education, health education and teacher education. Illustrative publications are the 1997 book "Risk and our pedagogical relation to children: On the playground and beyond," and the 2004 book, "The bearing of inquiry in teacher education." His recent work addresses vitality and physical mindfulness as overarching concepts of physical education and, more broadly speaking, of a somatic approach to teacher education. His scholarship draws inspiration from a range of traditional and alternative movement disciplines from games and sports to circus and equestrian arts. Email: [email protected] Page 14 of 14

File: enlivening-the-curriculum-of-health-related-fitness.pdf
Title: Educational Insights | Volume 13, Number 4, 2009 | Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith | Enlivening the Curriculum of Health-Related Fitness
Author: Rebecca J. Lloyd and Stephen J. Smith
Published: Sun Jan 3 22:57:21 2010
Pages: 14
File size: 0.55 Mb

The Case for Christ, 16 pages, 0.2 Mb

, pages, 0 Mb

Master of the Game, 271 pages, 1.09 Mb
Copyright © 2018 doc.uments.com