management accounting, introductory accounting, cost analysis, non-current assets, accounting, Greg Van Mourik Monash University, current assets, statement of cash flows, McGraw-Hill Australia, income statement, David H. Marshall, debits and credits, accounting principles, technical aspects, Jean P McCartney Di, cost accounting, introductory unit, International Accounting Standards, Noah P. Barsky, text, Practice Analysis of Management Accounting, process costing, Institute of Management Accountants, business processes, Sack Report on Accounting Education, financial performance evaluation, business planning, business plan, Anthony H. Catanach Houghton Mifflin, Monash University, cross-disciplinary, traditional methods, workplace context
Vol. 4 · Number 2 · 2006
Book Reviews Management Accounting: A Business Plan
ning Approach By Noah P. Barsky Anthony H. Catanach Houghton Mifflin (2005) 390 pages ISBN 0 618 21375 9 Reviewed By: Greg Van Mourik Monash University
The authors intend for this text to be an introductory accounting text and its primary goal to help both undergraduate and graduate students
gain an appreciation for the value of managerial accounting information. The reviewer regards this text as perhaps exceptional in terms of how interesting, perhaps even motivating, students are likely to find it. The text owes this character to its workplace context; not only via its reference to real world examples and case studies, but more so because the management accounting topics are linked to the various Strategic Planning
, Resource Management
and performance management activities commonly performed by business managers. This appears to benefit students by demonstrating the practical value of management accounting techniques and by assisting them to visualise themselves using the skills in the workplace. Specifically, the management accounting topics treated by the text are in respect to business strategy
modern business processes, financial performance evaluation, risk, planning, forecasting, budgeting, decision making, and cost analysis at the customer and process levels. Further reinforcing the business planning context, an appendix provides a thorough treatment of the preparation, presentation and review of a business plan. This increases the appeal of this text to courses which seek to maintain a strong cross-disciplinary character. As an introductory management accounting text, and in response to calls for an `overhaul' of education focus from what accountants "used to do", (The Institute of Management Accountants' 1999 Practice Analysis of Management Accounting, the Albrecht and Sack Report on Accounting Education) this text has de-emphasised topics relating to cost accumulation. In fact, topics relating to cost types, the flow of costs in a manufacturing firm, traditional methods
of overhead allocation, activity-based costing, and job and process costing systems are all dealt with in a single chapter. This may limit the applicability of this text for current courses. Perhaps predictably, the reviewer's main reservation with this text is its American context
. Notwithstanding that however, the text is an admirable and valuable resource to those wishing to study management accounting topics within a strong business context.
Vol. 4 · Number 2 · 2006
Accounting: What the Numbers Mean By David H. Marshall Jean P McCartney Di van Rhyn Wayne W McManus Daniel F Viele McGraw-Hill Australia (2005) 605 pages ISBN 0 07 471350 7. Reviewed By: Greg Van Mourik Monash University This text is intended for a one-semester introductory accounting unit covering both financial and management accounting topics at either undergraduate or postgraduate level
s. It is an adaptation from a US textbook, now in its sixth edition. Apart from incorporating the changes expected following Australia's adoption of International Accounting Standards, a distinctive feature of this text is that Accounting Principles
are introduced through the accounting equation meaning that the technical aspects of accounting procedures, debits and credits are not given prominence. This means that the focus of the book is teaching users what the "numbers mean" rather than "how to do it" and this is very appropriate given the text's objective of serving students of a one semester introductory unit. For the more curious student, coverage of the technical aspects of debits and credits and journal entries is provided in an Appendix. The financial accounting topics include financial statements, concepts and
principles; interpreting statements; the accounting process; current assets; non-current assets; accounting for liabilities and owners' equity; the income statement and statement of cash flows; and governance. The management accounting topics include cost types and CVP relationships, cost accounting and reporting systems; cost analysis for planning and control; and cost analysis for decision making. Consistent with the previously discussed emphasis on what the "numbers mean", generally the text provides relatively high level descriptions of accounting techniques and the quantitative examples and exercises tend to be simple. As such, the text is equipping the student with the ability to understand concepts, use appropriate language and ask the right questions of an accountant who is skilled in the in depth use of these techniques. Given the technical aspects of accounting is not given prominence, the text is suitable for use in general business courses as well as an introductory unit for students wishing to progress to more advanced accounting studies.